Class of 1953 Commons dedicated

The photo accompanying the press release on the recent pre-renovation dedication shows that the word THAYER has been replaced with the words CLASS OF 1953 COMMONS over the door of the building. (The inverted display of the Dartmouth flag is understood to indicate a beverage emergency.)

One of the biggest problems with Thayer seems to be that building’s kitchen gets extremely hot. The Dartmouth reported recently that a 250-ton air conditioning unit will be placed on the building’s roof in the upcoming renovation. Reed Construction Data lists Kieran Timberlake as the architects but seems to describe the earlier full-replacement project, notwithstanding the mere $500,000 cost projection.

Architecture topics in the Upper Valley

  • Keep checking the Six South Street Hotel blog for construction photos.
  • The New York Times had an article back in 2008 on the legal incentives to identifying “ancient roads” in Vermont. It brings to mind the observations of Christopher Lenney in Sightseeking: Clues to the Landscape History of New England (2005).
  • The Hanover Conservation Council provides maps and other information on sites including Mink Brook and Fullington Farm, the latter in the news because it is the site of the boathouse of the Hanover High crew.
  • The St. Gaudens National Historic Site in Cornish, just a few miles away from Hanover, has purchased Blow-Me-Down Farm (Valley News).
  • Alumni Relations has a gallery of campus trees. Number 7 is the Parkhurst Elm.

—–
[Update 03.31.2013: Broken link to Mink Brook replaced and Fullington Farm removed.]

Zeta Psi addition completed

The “Fuller Audits” of house compliance with town safety codes have led to a variety of responses over the past eight or so years, from Gamma Delta Chi’s minimal fire escape to the demolition of Sigma Phi Epsilon. (Phi Tau’s Fuller Audit played a role in its demolition as well.) Most organizations have added a bay or two to the end of the house to enclose a fire stair.

One of the most visible and insightful projects is the one recently completed by Zeta Psi (photos, more). Jens Larson’s firm designed the original house to face north toward Webster Avenue, away from the campus. Smith & Vansant Architects added a gabled portico to the rear, acknowledging the fact that most people approach from that direction.

Here it was under construction, from the Avenue side:



View Larger Map

—–
[Update 03.31.2013: Broken links to Zeta Psi photos removed, replaced with renovation page link.]

Pong as worthy of study

Judging from the papers and a 2005 visit, pong has been growing more popular and also more susceptible to careful study with an eye to history and aesthetics. (See The Dartmouth (2005), The Dartmouth Independent (2005 summer tournament, interesting), (2009).)

It is inevitable that an art exhibit would result (The Dartmouth).

—–
[Update 12.02.2012: Broken links to Dartmouth Independent articles removed.]

The Life Sciences Center and its antecedents

The Dartmouth ran an article on May 7th about perceptions of the cost of the Life Sciences Center and included a photo of the building in progress. The webcam has a current view.

A time-lapse film of the demolition of the intriguing and notable but appropriately-unloved Strasenburgh Hall is available.

The firm designing the Life Sciences Center, Bohlin Cywinski Jackson, is responsible for the fifth-most photographed site in all of New York City: the Apple Store on Fifth Avenue (NPR).

—–
[Update 01.13.2013: Broken link to Philly replaced with link to NPR.]
[Update 11.17.2012: Broken link to webcam removed.]

“Cribbing,” i.e. cheating

Rauner has an article on a wooden-roller crib sheet crafted by a member of the class of 1893. “Cribbing” (cheating) seems to have been widely practiced and talked about in nineteenth-century colleges.

An 1873 article[1] purports to reprint an 1844 letter discussing the practice of buying from a doctor a fake certificate that would excuse a student from classes. The class histories written for Class Day refer often to cheating, such as those of 1879 (describing a student’s “elaborately-written cribs” and the help given by a nearby student during an exam)[2] and 1883.[3] Professor Edwin Bartlett wrote that an employee of the Dartmouth Hotel once confessed to have stolen exam questions from his room in the 1879-1881 period.[4] “I never should have guessed it from the papers handed in,” Bartlett wrote.

A relatively late comment on cribs appears in a 1910 essay in the Jack-O-Lantern: “They are found in meny shapes and everybuddy youses um.”[5]

Last month The Dartmouth published a three-part series on cheating.

———-
[1] “The Reprobate Sophs,” The Dartmouth 7:9 (November 1873), 361-64.
[2] Daniel Arthur Rollins, “History of the Class of Seventy-nine. Dartmouth College” (Hanover, N.H.: Dartmouth Class of 1879, 1878), 32.
[3] William White Niles, “Chronicles,” in “Exercises of Class Day at Dartmouth College, Tuesday, June 26, 1883” (Hanover, N.H.: Class of 1883, 1883), 37.
[4] Edwin J. Bartlett, A Dartmouth Book of Remembrance: Pen and Camera Sketches of Hanover and the College Before the Centennial and After (Hanover, N.H.: The Webster Press, 1922), 43.
[5] Willie [___], “Essay on Cribs,” Jack-O-Lantern 2:5 (February 1910), [n.p.].

Graphic design and signage

The library had a contest to select a design for its new favicon/logo, formerly the tilted D. The winners (pdf) are surprisingly heraldic.

This might have been mentioned before, but the staff in the DMS shield has been genericized. It used to be an Indian-head cane.

Dartmouth has its own typeface, or at least the capital letters for a typeface, writes the Rauner blog. Will Carter designed Dartmouth title (Rauner’s sample) around 1969 for use in inscriptions in the teak panels in the Hopkins Center. The present king of collegiate typefaces seems to be Matthew Carter’s ca. 2008 Yale (see also Yale Daily News article), although Frederic Goudy’s 1938 University Old Style for Berkeley is an earlier example that lives on in Richard Beatty’s 1994 redrawing as UC Berkeley Old Style.

For years, Smith College tapped into certain associations (unintentionally?) by using ITC Garamond, which paralleled the Apple Garamond of Apple Computer advertisements at the time (Wikipedia on Apple typography; Smith’s current Visual Identity Program). The quality of the design itself is important, and distinctiveness is not everything (see the Typotheque article on the modification of Brioni for Al Gore).

With the Visual Arts Center about to go up next door to the Hopkins Center, it’s time to finally commission an artist (Colossal Media, say) to paint signs on the Hop’s largely-blank rear walls. The walls of Spaulding Auditorium (Street View) and the huge fly loft at the rear of the Moore Theater are ripe for advertisement.




Sign concept for west facade of studio row, Hopkins Center (partially based on a photo from http://philip.greenspun.com).

The destruction of a genuine ghost sign at the unique industrial/commercial campus of the University of Washington, Tacoma recently caused some controversy (News Tribune).

—–
[Update 11.17.2012: Broken link to Smith program fixed.]

Rauner’s blog keeps going

Rauner Library’s blog has sent out a raft of interesting illustrated posts lately, on Howard Lines 1912 and his memorial in Baker; SS Dartmouth Victory, a Victory Ship; Adrian Bouchard, Dartmouth’s official photographer from 1937 to 1976, except for the 1941-1945 period; Orozco and his frescoes in Baker; and gravestones of the Risley family, stonecutters in the early nineteenth century.

[Update 07.28.2010: Erroneous Bouchard years 1837 to 1876 corrected.]

Eking out progress on the Visual Arts Center

Bruce Wood at the Big Green Alert Blog has some up-to-date photos of the site preparations.

Numerous plans and bidding documents are now on line. The Trustees report saving almost $10 million by refining the contractor bidding process. Building contractor Berry has a project page up.

The architects have their VAC page back up, but without significant information. The school’s design office has been able to go a year without updating their general projects page, indicating the depth of the slowdown.

The latest Alumni Magazine notes the critique of an architect, that the VAC does not fit into its context. Comments available at NPR and The Chronicle say similar things. It will be interesting to see the final result of this project, considering that much of the building’s context is not red brick at all, which is what the critics seem to refer to. The building will stand right across the street from C&A Pizza:



View Larger Map

—–
[Update 03.31.2013: Broken link to Berry & Son removed.]

The Alumni Magazine on architecture

The May/June 2010 issue of the Dartmouth Alumni Magazine focuses on architecture and includes “Alumni Opinion: Return of the Critic” by William Morgan and “Architectural Digest” by C.J. Hughes. The latter article profiles alumni architects and makes the case for the quality of Dartmouth’s architectural education. I would like to read a history of that education some time, going back through instructors Banwell and the Hunters to Larson and Keyes and eventually, in the 1850s, to the Chandler School.


Chandler School


The Chandler School, on the vacant lot south of Blunt. The top floor of the rear addition was a skylit drafting studio. The building was expanded twice by alumni architects, both of whom had studied architecture inside. The frame building at left is Hubbard Hall, a temporary dormitory.

[Update 06.15.2010: The DAM article is up.]

The “virtual” campus and the physical

The explosion of online universities makes the contemplation of the future American college campus an interesting and fruitful proposition.

The variety of online institutions is impressive. One the one hand, there is the vast and partly-physical University of Phoenix, whose Peter Eisenman/Populous University of Phoenix Stadium was not actually made for intercollegiate athletics. On the other hand, there is the little “Yorktown University,” which runs courses for high-school students and grants credits for “life experiences” from a rented office above a Denver tanning salon. (The founder’s “Today in History” calendar doesn’t suggest that an intellectual environment prevails even there, since it credits Joseph Conrad with the authorship of The Red Badge of Courage — by Stephen Crane.) The costs saved by avoiding a physical campus would seem to allow these virtual schools to take considerable business away from traditional colleges.

It is also popular to say that the traditional college will not vanish entirely. Some students who value the old-fashioned ways will always exist, and “there will always be a Harvard.” I would go one step further: in line with the rule, attributed to Ferry Porsche, that the last car ever built will be a sports car, one could predict that the last university to survive will be a “real” one, not an online institution.

Real-world schools are developing their grounds more intensely and planning them more thoughtfully than they have in decades. Along with the maturation of the “virtual” university, any school that has a spatial presence and a sense of place seems to be making its physical campus even more of a selling point. The standards for campus design continue to rise, and university planners these days are expressly incorporating the neo-traditional principles of the New Urbanism (see also the Congress for the New Urbanism; some argue that it was only university planners that kept these principles alive for the city during the Dark Ages of Modernist planning).

Fascinating plans, for example, continue to come out of the office Michael Dennis & Associates, famous for its Classical and traditionalist Carnegie Mellon plan, a plan that is just as notable for the fact that much of it actually got built. The firm’s 2004 master plan for Texas A&M (under Projects, also depicted at the school’s master planning site) is worth viewing and comparing to what exists today. No one knows how much pressure A&M is feeling from online competitors, but it is clear that its campaign to reclaim vast expanses of empty space is much more than simply “beautification.”

—–
[Update 05.03.2014: Broken link to accreditation loss notice replaced.]
[Update 05.03.2013: Yorktown University (a.k.a. “DontQuitU,” which is not a smoking-cessation product) lost its accreditation during 2012 and now seems to be running a Sports Management degree program out of Florida under the names “Yorktown University of the Americas” and “EDUCourses.” The institution gets to keep its .edu domain name even if it no longer meets the requirements established by Educause.]
[Update 11.17.2012: Broken links caused by curly quotes fixed; broken link to calendar at “yorktowncollege.com” removed; broken links to Porsche quote and CMU replaced; broken links to TAMU depiction and illustrations fixed; broken link to existing map replaced.]

The old Howe Library’s stacks addition

A recent post mentioned that the second floor of the brick addition to the old house at 2 West Wheelock Street is available for rent.

Howe stacks addition
Stacks addition, east facade, view to northwest

Here is some more information on the addition:

In 1900, Emily Howe established the Howe Library in the house where she had grown up (Eleazar Wheelock’s Mansion House, built in 1771 with funds sent from London for the purpose). Howe died in 1912 and left much of her estate to the library corporation, which hired architect Curtis W. Bixby of Watertown, Mass. to design a fireproof addition for book stacks. The addition was built in 1914 and 1915 and displays a level of detail that is unexpected for a background building.

Howe stacks addition
Stacks addition, entrance in east facade

The Howe moved to its current location in the early 1970s and the old building became a shop, with Roberts Flowers of Hanover moving in during 1990.

Another Bixby building of 1915 is the Coolidge School in Watertown, which he designed with Clarence P. Hoyt. The school is now an apartment building and shares some elements with the Howe’s stacks addition.

—–
[Update 05.03.2014: Broken link to Roberts Flowers replaced.]

Fraternity to demolish historic Webster Avenue house

Sigma Phi Epsilon fraternity is planning to demolish its 1896 house at 11 Webster Avenue. It will submit its application for site plan review to the Planning Board on April 20th.


Historic Sigma Phi Epsilon House at Dartmouth before demolition

11 Webster Avenue in 2005

The clapboard house, attributed to Boston architects Dwight & Chandler, was built for math professor Thomas W.D. Worthen of the Class of 1872. The house was part of an original row of six contemporary faculty dwellings by the same firm.

The society occupied the house for more than 50 years and added the large righthand wing by well-known local architects Alfred T. Granger & Associates in 1958.

The fraternity has obtained a special exception [ZBA Minutes 02.04.2010 pdf] from the zoning board to erect a new building on the site.

Sig Ep’s house is not the most exciting one on the Avenue, but still, the Town should ask the group to document the existing structure before demolishing it (Claremont documents the historic buildings it demolishes).

Better yet, the fraternity should voluntarily document its own house before tearing it down. Although not the same as preservation, it would be better than nothing.

—–
[Update 01.13.2013: Broken links to two pdfs removed.]
[Update 05.01.2010: Sig Ep at Wisconsin, rebuilding its house after a fire, had to win approval for the design from the local Landmarks Commission. The house is located in a historic district.]

[Update 07.28.2010: The Dartmouth has a drawing of the front facade of the replacement. Planning Board minutes (04.20.2010 pdf) suggest that Domus, Inc. of Etna is participating in the project.]

Ideas for a new heating plant

Heating Plant
Dartmouth Heating Plant

The trend these days seems to be for colleges to drop coal (and probably oil, which is what powers Dartmouth’s plant) and go with natural gas, as at Cornell, or biomass, as at Middlebury.

From a planning standpoint alone, a new heating plant would be beneficial for Dartmouth. It would allow the Studio Art department to colonize the well-worn but supremely adaptable old heating plant. Assuming that a steam plant works as well at one end of the line as the other, Dartmouth could build an up-to-date replacement in what might be called the development zone north of the Life Sciences Center, an area that arguably should be developed densely and like a town, not like a campus.

Dartmouth is pragmatic enough that it might do a new heating plant as a metal shed. But because this is a gateway to campus, and for art’s sake, Dartmouth should have an interesting architect do it. No need to cite the great power plants through history, just look at this chiller plant at Chicago:

This is not to say that Hanover needs a building that looks like one by Murphy/Jahn, only that the utilitarian parts of campus could stand to be invested with some artistry.

Publications, including a 1954 Carnival film

This has probably been mentioned here before: “Dartmouth by Air,” a video by the Media Production Group, is worth watching.

The red jeep visible alongside the Green in this postcard appears in a 1954 film. Bill Miles '56 notes in the comments that he played Freddy and that Bob Black '56 played Eddy in the film. The Alpha Delta house stands in for a dormitory in the serenade scene.

Rauner’s blog has several photos of skijoring at Carnival.

Transcripts of President Hopkins’s oral-history interviews from 1958 to 1964 are now available (see also Rauner blog).

Steve Waterhouse '65 has written A Passion for Skiing about Dartmouth’s contribution to the skiing industry (Vail Today).

—–
[Update 05.12.2013: Broken link to Vail Today fixed.]
[Update 11.17.2012: Broken postcard link fixed.]

Sigourney Weaver as Eleazar Wheelock

In Avatar (2009), colonist Jake is surprised to learn that some of the native Na’vi speak English. He asks and is told that they learned English at Dr. Augustine’s School. This exchange mirrors one in The Last of the Mohicans (1992) in which Cora asks Hawkeye how he learned to speak English, and he replies:

My father sent Uncas & I to Reverend Wheelock’s school when I was ten.

(From the Michael Mann and Christopher Crowe script, not in Cooper’s original — although Susan F. Cooper discusses Wheelock in her introduction to later editions such as the 1876 edition.)

—–
[Update 12.02.2012: Broken link to Mohicans and script at IMDB fixed.]

Buildings – construction, some demolition

Rauner Library has provided a remarkable photo of the Butterfield Museum embraced in a death-hug by Baker Library. This is a view of the south and east facades of the east wing of Baker, looking to the northwest. The problem of Butterfield appears to have had a significant influence on the design of Baker.

See also the photos of the bells and the steel frame of the tower under construction.

With historic Clement Hall demolished (film and photos), the Visual Arts Center construction has been put out for bid.

Phi Delt reconstruction continues, The Dartmouth reports.

Engleberth Construction provides photos of the Tuck Living-Learning Center (Achtmeyer, Raether, and Pineau-Valencienne Halls).

It is not new, but Forever New: A 10-Year Report provides a comprehensive photo of the interior-block facades of Kemeny-Haldeman not available elsewhere.